Hi @pierre-gilles ,
Hard question, I’m just typing along with my toughts, which can become a long read.
The Ideal World
In the ideal world there’s just one community, where posts are automatically translated into either English or French (based on the users preferences). Discourse has a Translator-plugin in the pro version, but even that plugin is far from this ideal world.
Some Analysis
I myself am reading along in the French forum with a translator-plugin. Not only is that forum much more lively, it also has more valuable content, like tutorials and problems being solved. Why is that? I think: some of the active French speaking users and developers are on both forums. But they’re more actively contributing on the French one. And I can imagine. If there were a Dutch forum, that would be my main hangout.
And I think that’s the core of it. Gladys is born as a French project. It has a big French userbase. With a French YouTube-presence, mainly French developers and over 720 French forum-users.
On the English side there is no YouTube-presence (yet), mainly bi-lingual developers (with French as their first language) and only 54 English forum-users (of which some are in both fora).
Possible Actions
So as long as the ideal world is still far away I think the key is twofold:
- to tempt current bilingual users and developers to get more active on the English forum.
- to attract more users and developers who are primarily non-French.
The second one can be achieved by creating valuable, cross-platform content in English like YouTube-tutorials and social media presence. This will direct people to Gladys. And also by adding more content to at least the Configuration and Tutorial categories in the forum. It has to feel as if there are
- answers available if you run into something, and
- constantly people answering to questions (by now I know that’s the case, but a newbe doesn’t know that).
Maybe the adding of information can in a way be automated, with fx. IFTTT and ChatGPT (didn’t dive into that).
Some Thoughts on Competion
Finally some thoughts on competition. Althought Gladys is much more user friendly than Open Source competitors like Home Assistant, OpenHab and Domoticz, they still are competition. The same goes for closed source (more or less user friendly) competitors like Smartthings, Hubitat, Homey or even Tuya Smart. All of these are multilingual. And the Open Source competitors also have a very active (in the case of Home Assistant even very vocal) English fanbase. So that’s some hard competition to deal with, also in attracting active users and developers. And that’s I guess a big difference with the French Gladys, as being the only rather serious French Open Source Smart Home platform. So the growing pace just might not be that fast.